Education, Medical Issues, Well-being
by Ramon P. Llamas, MPH, CHES May 27, 2010
Do women make better doctors? A recent editorial by Pauline Chen, M.D. in the New York Times posed this thought-provoking question, which led me to recall my previous experiences with physicians of both genders. It is an interesting concept when you think about it. So many of the same qualities that mothers generally have – caring, compassion and a nurturing spirit – were possessed by many of the women doctors that I have interacted with. I won’t go so far as to say that I prefer a female physician over a male, but just based on past experiences, I felt more comfortable when cared for by a female physician. And while research studies do support the theory that female doctors are considered “better” in the patient’s perspective, the literature also indicates that the patient’s gender also plays an important role. Dr. Chen indicates that female patients had particular expectations depending on their physician’s gender. For example, when seen by female physicians, they reported satisfaction when physicians expressed great concern and empathy during the visit. In contrast, female patients were more satisfied with male physicians who did not overtly show concern or empathy. Male patients, on the other hand reported satisfaction, regardless of the physician’s gender. Moreover, female patients were more likely to engage in discussions with their physician regarding their illness compared to their male counterparts.
Continue Reading